Monday 24 September 2007

The myth of exogenous risk and the recent quant problems

Regular readers of my work will know that I am deeply skeptical over the idea of exogenous risk (like a gambler playing roulette, where the behaviour of other players is irrelevant). In Chapter 36 of Behavioural Investing I argue that many aspect of risk are endogenous ( like a gambler playing poker, where the actions of the other plays are integral to the game) to the way in which we invest. The problems experienced by the quant funds in August may help highlight some of these issues.

Now as my post on the 17 August detailed I suspect that leverage had much to do with the problems experienced by the quant funds. As one observation reader commented the hubristic use of excessive leverage is an all too human failing, and has nothing do to with the 'quant' process as such.

Andrew Lo (of MIT) and Amir Khandani have written a fascinating paper on the problems of August (available here ). They use indirect evidence to establish the scale of the issue and the kind of problems to be encountered. They use a very simple contrarian strategy of simply buying yesterdays losers, and selling yesterday's winners on a daily basis. They ignore all the issues surrounding transaction costs and turnover, as this is only an example.

They document several interesting features using this simple strategy. The first is alpha cannibalisation (or alpha decay as they call it). As more and more funds have set up in the quant arena so the return to this strategy has declined from an average daily return of 1.38% in 1995, to a mere 0.13% in 2007.

They show that in order to increase the return back to the level seen in 1998, leverage of around 8-times would have been required. As noted in my original post Goldmans Global Equity Opportunity fund was running 6 times! They also show that this strategy performed exceptionally badly in August. It witnessed several consecutive days in August (nearly 7% over 3 days, a 12 standard deviation event).

In a comparsion between 1998 and 2007, Lo and Khandani show that the big difference between 1998 and 2007 is the lack of spillover in the LTCM crisis. Whilst markets had a turblent time as LTCM problems became widely known in the wake of the Asian and Russian crises, simple quant strategies continued to work.

This hints at one possible (perhaps even probable) cause of August's events. A multi-strategy funds (or prop desk) took a big hit in the mortgage/CDO space, and as a result was forced to scale back on operations across the board, terminating their positions in equity space.

This in turn probably caused other quant funds to hit their limits, and unleashed a vicious spiral of selling, and further selling. The more crowded a trade is, the more likely this outcome becomes.

A survey for the the CFA publication Trends in Quantitative Finance (April 2006) showed that out of 21 firms using quant, 18 used them for return forecasting (with around $2 trillion invested in equities). The most popular factors uncovered were 'reversal' with 86% of those questioned citing it's use. In second place came 'momentum' with 81%, and in third was exogenous factors (such as valuations, earnings quality, capex ect) with 62% of respondents using such methods.

The recent so called 'quant problems' are a timely reminder of the endogenous nature of risk in our markets.

58 comments:

Anonymous said...

At the risk of repeating myself, the problem with quant funds is they don't care. If too many people don't care, bad behaviours and bad things begin to happen. Rather like index funds, quant funds are effectivey anti- capitalist and should be banned - but they won't be.

Anonymous said...

wIjh9S Your blog is great. Articles is interesting!

Anonymous said...

hChGj7 Wonderful blog.

Anonymous said...

RZCDTw Good job!

Anonymous said...

Wonderful blog.

Anonymous said...

Thanks to author.

Anonymous said...

Hello all!

Anonymous said...

Nice Article.

Anonymous said...

Hello all!

Anonymous said...

Magnific!

Anonymous said...

Please write anything else!

Anonymous said...

QJNoLz Good job!

Anonymous said...

Good job!

Ricardo Leiton said...

hello friend thanks for collect and post this information about The myth of exogenous risk and the recent quant problems, I 'm very interesting in this topic about health because I need to Buy Viagrafor this reason I'm looking information about health

Anonymous said...

clomid hot flashes day 15

asterhealthsource said...

Yes,May people never realize about their bad behavior.I think you highlighted some thing very important issue which is very important for us.
generic viagra pharmacy

marven said...

There are may person searching about that article, logo design

admin said...

Pleasantly, the posting is really the contemporary niche for this registry related issue. I harmonize along with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your incoming updates. Simply say gives thanks is not going to sufficient, in your lucidity in your posting. I’ll immediately grab your rss feed to keep abreast of all updates.

how to get rid of cellulite

Unknown said...

Nice post! Thanks for sharing!
Buy Xenical

MLB2k11 said...

Nice post. Thanks fro sharing. It was very interesting and meaningful. Keep posting. I follow you.
Yelp Clone Script| Angry birds clone| Groupon Clone| Groupon Clone Script|

Anonymous said...

I was interested know about it lesbian bondage sex

adlai said...

the Issues in your site is really cool..keep it up..thanks for sharing it to us..

phone spy software for the safety of my phone.Android phone locator for the tracking of my location.
android gps apps locator and tracking my route.

android tracker also a tracker for my gps.

track cell phone location
cell phone locator
phone tracker
gps track cell phone
gps tracking
trackcellphone

Ricky Martin said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Silviu said...

I am glad that I found your blog cause I was searching for a long time for this topic that you approached.

Toldes bani din forex Radaceni

anita grace said...

Thanks for your post, I like this post very much.
Birthday parties for kids in Miami
Kids birthday parties in Miami

Anonymous said...

I enjoyed following the whole entry, I always thought one of the main things to count when you write a blog is learning how to complement the ideas with images, that's exploiting at the maximum the possibilities of a pharmacy escrow! Good work on this entry!

Fara Fae said...

I will forward this article to him. Pretty sure he will have a good read. Thanks for sharing!

Tubal Reversals | Tubal Ligation reversal Surgery

Farrah Khan said...

Casi la gente le gusta escribir lo que dijo, pero me gusta escuchar lo que dijo, su mensaje es muy bueno. Gracias!


nutricionista Barcelona | dietista Barcelona | dietas Barcelona

iori said...

Wonderful post. I am searching awesome news and idea. What I have found
from your site, it is actually highly content. You have spent long time
for this post. It's a very useful and interesting site. Thanks!

saim said...

Nice post. We are impressed by your clear description of your topic. Thanks for the information. Keep on writing.

find doctor list

iori said...

Hi there,
You have done really nice job. There are many people searching about that now they
will find enough sources by your tips.
looking forward for more tips about that
Natural supplements
organic supplements
Testosterone Booster Supplement

Abby said...

Beautifully expressed article, i really enjoyed my stay on this plus wonderful website
natural supplements

iori said...

testimonial voiceovers
I agree with you. This post is truly inspiring. I like your post and everything
you share with us is current and very informative, I want to bookmark the page
so I can return here from you that you have done a fantastic job ...



testimonial voiceovers

brandan said...

Very good customer service, prompt delivery (lol...prompt for coming from so far away!), and good products. I recommend this company to my friends all the time. is a godsend to those of us without medical insurance.
buy medicine

Isabella Kaun said...

I like the valuable information you provide in your articles. I’ll bookmark your weblog and check again here frequently.
Natural Colon Cleanser

Farrah Khan said...

I am incomparable to enjoy myself when i appreciate your beautiful article from my deep heart!

~^- organic supplements -^~

Unknown said...

Hi, I found your post really helpful. Thanks for posting such informative content. Keep posting.
doctor ratings and reviews

0Zero7 said...

They just make me feel fresh and energetic. That’s the magic of your articles .
web hosting Pakistan

Unknown said...

I am bowled from your level of know-how. I am so impressed. There's no doubt that you have got an in-depth insight into this particular topic.
find doctors list

doctor ratings and reviews

iori said...

Hi there,
You have done really nice job. There are many people searching about that now they
will find enough sources by your tips.
looking forward for more tips about that

3d ultrasounds
4d ultrasounds
4d3d ultrasounds

anita grace said...

weight loss spray
I really appreciate your post. Game theory is gives an outstanding idea that is very helpful for all the people on the web.

James Smith said...

Nice post. I enjoyed your post a lot. It is so interesting that I couldn't take away
my eyes from your blog.I Enjoyed reading it a lot. Best of luck!!
Lakeview boot camp

anita grace said...

Appetite Control spray
Nice effort, very informative, this will help me to complete my task.

Fara Fae said...

It is so lucky to read your blog; it is full of useful message. I wish we both can do better in the future. It great honor if you can visit our website, and give us some suggestion.

tubal reversal surgery | reversal of tubal ligation

anita grace said...

naturalsleep aid
I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles very nice.

anita grace said...

Curcumin helped stop the spread of breast cancer tumor cells to the lungs of mice.
buy curcumin
curcumin

Majid Hussain said...

Curcumin, the major polyphenol found in turmeric, appears to reduce weight gain in mice and suppress the growth of fat tissue in mice and cell models.
curcumin
buy curcumin

iori said...

Great blog. All posts have something to learn. Your work is very good and
i appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts.
thank you
dieta online
dietas online

Elysian said...

Some people really make difference. Blog carries great informative material. One should read this one and appreciate. Thanks.
Dubai apartments

Isabella Kaun said...

One of the benefits of organic foods is that they do not have as many chemicals such as pesticides on or in them. Also, many studies have shown organic foods to have higher levels of some nutrients. Some of these minerals were Calcium and Magnesium.
organic supplements
=|=natural supplements
=|=organic vitamins

joli said...

I mean, I have never been so entertained by anything in my life! Thanks for sharing such a nice post.
manhattan locksmith

Isabella Kaun said...

I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style of blogging.
24 hour locksmiht

Isabella Kaun said...

At the chance of duplicating myself, the issue with quant resources is they don't care. If too many people don't care, bad behaviors and bad factors start to occur. Rather like catalog resources, quant resources are effectivey anti- naturalist and should be prohibited - but they won't be.

Compra Oro Plata

Unknown said...

I have never been so interested by anything in my life! Thanks for discussing such a good publish.
Internet Marketing Consultant

Robert Ray said...

The utmost out of hram’s way mode is used to get your being a refurbishing visage throughout. This lucrative company offer prompt services along with shower filter an gets an all rounder that caters and cherish your body needs beyond your expectations and imaginations.electromagnetic radiation

Anonymous said...

Hello! I simply would really like to present large thumbs up for the nice information you’ve got here on this post. i’ll be coming to your journal for a lot of before long cheap jersey

Unknown said...

Nice Post Love Reading Its

caverta

generic Viagra 100mg

kamagra 100mg

Tadalis

caris said...

https://www.guest-articles.com/education/aws-certified-solutions-architect-professional-03-12-2020